Our guide to the best eats in Pine Hill, Belleayre & Big Indian.
Cozy, Character-Filled Eats in the Catskills
The Catskills offers a dining experience rooted in warmth, creativity, and a strong sense of community. Pine Hill, in the heart of the Catskills, is a small mountain hamlet known for its relaxed pace and thoughtfully crafted food scene that complements the region’s natural beauty.
A Thoughtful and Welcoming Food Culture
Restaurants in the Catskills focus on comfort, seasonality, and authenticity. Meals feel personal and intentional, often inspired by the surrounding landscape and the changing seasons. Dining here is as much about slowing down as it is about the food itself.
Our Favorites
Peekamoose – Big Indian
Local favorites like Peekamoose Restuarent & Tap Room offer elevated comfort food with a focus on local ingredients and a warm, inviting atmosphere.
The Print House – Fleischmanns
The Print House brings a casual, creative energy to Pine Hill, known for its thoughtfully crafted menu, laid-back vibe, and strong sense of place. For bold flavors and a fun, relaxed atmosphere,
Tito’s Banditos – Pine Hill
Tito’s Banditos is a go-to for vibrant Mexican-inspired dishes and casual dining.
Our favorite Catskills restaurants feel intimate and unpretentious, offering welcoming spaces where visitors can unwind after time spent outdoors. The dining scene reflects the character of the Catskills—simple, soulful, and deeply connected to place. Whether you are fresh off a mountain hike or coming right off the slopes at Belleayre Mountain, these local gems are perfect for refueling with locally inspired menus, cozy interiors, and an atmosphere that invites you to linger just a little longer.And don’t forget, guests at Gateway Lodge – Catskills in Pine Hill are offered daily free breakfast in our communal dining rooms. With options for all including vegetarian, vegan and gluten-free options. Guests return year after year for our hearty classics and healthy options.
